Thursday, November 18, 2010

What are we Reading?!

Just to let you guys know we have been reading the Nicomachean Ethics. The page numbers are wrong on the agenda bc I didnt realize you guys were getting a different edition of the text than mine. I broke up the book into three different class days. We have covered the first 2/3 in class so far. For tonight I want you to read the last 1/3, so by tomorrow you should have read the entirity of the Ethics.
Sorry for the confusion,
Dr. Layne

Incontinence

Analyze Aristotle's understanding of the incontinent man. Be sure to tell me how his actions relate to knowledge and desire. Furthermore, do you agree with Aristotle or Socrates on the question of whether incontinent action is even possible. In other words if you had true knowledge of the good could you act counter to that knowledge?

See you tomorrow,
Dr. Layne

Friday, November 12, 2010

Read until Book VI

Okay guys we discussed the ultimate end of all action for Aristotle today: happiness understood not as a psychological feeling but as the fulfillment of one's excellence. That is, the happy life becomes the life in its best or most flourishing state.

For next time tell me what Aristotle means by voluntary action and decision/deliberation. How are these two concepts related to virtue in general as well as justice in particular.

Have a happy (flourishing) weekend,
Dr. Layne 

Throwback: Protagoras




I came across this book on Amazon.com last night.Looking at it after studying Protagoras, its interesting to me that a book exists to teach parents how to teach their children virtues. Protagoras' belief that virtue must be taught in order to compensate for the relativity of justice and value is very present in today's society, as evidenced by this book. Its interesting that not only do we need to teach our children values, but we must first be taught how to teach them. It also got me thinking about the attitude each generation has towards the generations that come after. It seems that as people age, they adopt a "when I was your age" mentality towards those younger than them.Many people seem to view the generations below them as less moral or more resistant to the solid values of the good ol' days. Does this mean we are getting worse at teaching virtue? Are virtues becoming increasingly relative? Or, are virtues changing at a pace that prohibits them from being passed down to subsequent generations?



Thursday, November 11, 2010

fun story relating to Socrates' waves of paradox...

When reading the Republic I was especially interested in Socrates’ three waves of paradox, specifically the idea that women are equal and eugenics. Socrates essentially said that when males and females are born, they are the exact same, there are no difference between the two, besides the obvious. He is stating that he could raise a boy as a girl and have him be a completely normal girl and vice versa. I am refuting this idea. I was interested in this because it relates to what I am learning about in my developmental psychology class. We were discussing the classic “nature vs. nurture” controversy and a story was brought up about a male who when he was in surgery to be circumcised, the doctors made a HUGE mistake and accidently chopped off his private parts completely. The doctor’s simply said that since he was a baby, they could reconstruct his genitals into that of a female and that the parents could raise the child as a girl and that he (or she?) would function and develop like any normal girl. Unfortunately for the boy, this was not the case. His parents raised him as a girl, grew his hair out and put him in dresses and gave him estrogen hormones. The boy wasn’t informed of his true history until he was 14 and finally voiced his struggles growing up. He knew something was wrong and told his parents that he was a boy, without them even admitting the truth to him. Needless to say he had quite a messed up childhood and ended up unfortunately killing himself after years of reconstruction surgeries, a wife and children. This ultimately relates and refutes Socrates idea that males and females are the same when born. I thought this was just an interesting story that is relative to this idea of Socrates’.

Pop Quiz #3

WORLDVIEWS AND ETHICS
POP QUIZ #3

Directions: In the next twenty minutes you need to write out an answer to the question below clearly and concisely. Be sure to organize your thoughts so as to have a clear thesis statement supported by evidence. It might be helpful to organize your thoughts into an opening paragraph containing your thesis statement followed by two to three short body paragraphs which detail the reasons why you hold your particular thesis. Once “in-class writing” has been completed you will be allowed to take your answer home so that you may type it up and expand upon it. You are may edit your answer for clarity and add further evidence to your paper. Finally, you will be required to staple this written draft to your “final” typed up and edited draft on Friday Nov.  12. Final Quizzes need only be 1 page long of no less than 300 words but no more than 500. Please turn these two copies in along with posting your answer to the class blog. If you do not turn in your “hand written quiz” with your final copy, your grade will be lowered 1 point from the 5 total points possible.

Question: Using any of the theories of justice and the good from the Republic (Polemarchus, Thrasymachus, Glaucon or Socrates), tell me if justice is something good only for itself, good for itself and for its consequences or not good in itself but only for its consequences. If you choose to focus on Socrates be sure to integrate one of his defenses of the nature of justice/the good in the City/Soul Analogy, the Tripartite Division of the Soul, the Analogy of the Good, the Divided Line, the forms of Government corresponding to types of souls and/or they Myth of Er into your answer.

Tuesday, November 9, 2010

Aristotle's Ethics

So read Book I Chapters 1-13 of the Nicomachean Ethics.

What is the function of the human being and how does determine our good?

See you tomorrow,
Dr. Layne